Formalizing Dangerous SAT Encodings
نویسندگان
چکیده
In this paper we prove an exponential separation between two very similar and natural SAT encodings for the same problem, thereby showing that researchers must be careful when designing encodings, lest they accidentally introduce complexity into the problem being studied. This result provides a formal explanation for empirical results showing that the encoding of a problem can dramatically affect its practical solvability. We also introduce a domain-independent framework for reasoning about the complexity added to SAT instances by their encodings. This includes the observation that while some encodings may add complexity, other encodings can actually make problems easier to solve by adding clauses which would otherwise be difficult to derive within a Resolution-based SAT-solver. Such encodings can be used as polytime preprocessing to speed up SAT algorithms.
منابع مشابه
Towards Robust CNF Encodings of Cardinality Constraints
Motivated by the performance improvements made to SAT solvers in recent years, a number of different encodings of constraints into SAT have been proposed. Concrete examples are the different SAT encodings for ≤ 1 (x1, . . . , xn) constraints. The most widely used encoding is known as the pairwise encoding, which is quadratic in the number of variables in the constraint. Alternative encodings ar...
متن کاملSAT-Encodings for Special Treewidth and Pathwidth
Decomposition width parameters such as treewidth provide a measurement on the complexity of a graph. Finding a decomposition of smallest width is itself NP-hard but lends itself to a SAT-based solution. Previous work on treewidth, branchwidth and clique-width indicates that identifying a suitable characterization of the considered decomposition method is key for a practically feasible SAT-encod...
متن کاملModelling Max-CSP as Partial Max-SAT
We define a number of original encodings that map MaxCSP instances into partial Max-SAT instances. Our encodings rely on the well-known direct and support encodings from CSP into SAT. Then, we report on an experimental investigation that was conducted to compare the performance profile of our encodings on random binary Max-CSP instances. Moreover, we define a new variant of the support encoding...
متن کاملEncoding Basic Arithmetic Operations for SAT-Solvers
In this paper we start an investigation to check the best we can do with SAT encodings for solving two important hard arithmetic problems, integer factorization and discrete logarithm. Given the current success of using SAT encodings for solving problems with linear arithmetic constraints, studying the suitability of SAT for solving non-linear arithmetic problems was a natural step. However, ou...
متن کاملSequential Encodings from Max-CSP into Partial Max-SAT
We define new encodings from Max-CSP into Partial MaxSAT which are obtained by modelling the at-most-one condition with the sequential SAT encoding of the cardinality constraint ≤ 1(x1, . . . , xn). They have fewer clauses than the existing encodings, and the experimental results indicate that they have a better performance profile.
متن کامل